Comparing Different Flooring Materials

comparing different flooring materials

Whether you’re renovating your own home or working on a project for a client, choosing the right flooring is essential. Let’s face it, it isn’t easy. This is the case whether you’re grabbing materials for your next job or looking for a combination of style, value and durability.

Finding what works can be challenging. This is especially true in Florida homes where in-stock materials that deliver great value are important. Today, we will discuss and compare some of the most popular flooring materials: SPC, LVP, laminate, tile and engineered hardwood. Choose the flooring that fits your home, but always choose a reputable flooring store in Tampa, FL to make sure it’s sourced, installed, and warrantied the right way.

Factors to Consider When Shopping for Flooring Materials

With so many options available, how do you narrow down your options? Your best bet is to ask yourself a few questions. Think about the following:

  • Is the space prone to moisture?
  • Will this floor get heavy use?
  • Do you want comfort underfoot?
  • Are you working with a tight budget?
  • Is fast installation important?

When you answer these questions for yourself, you can determine what’s most important to you and buy flooring like a pro. After all, this will vary from person to person. 

Understanding Different Flooring Materials

There are several flooring materials available, but which one is right for you? Let us help you out. We will discuss what each flooring material is as their pros and cons. Let us break it down for you.

SPC (Stone Plastic Composite)

SPC flooring is heavy-duty, waterproof plank, pet-friendly flooring designed to resist wear. It doesn’t matter whether you’re dealing with job site dirt, water spills and heavy foot traffic. These floors are built to last. Consider using these floors in bathrooms entryways, commercial spaces and rental properties.

What makes these floors so great? Check out their benefits below:

  • Fully waterproof
  • Resists scratches and dents
  • Simple cleaning
  • Rigid and durable

Despite its many advantages, this flooring material has its shortcomings. These include:

  • Harder underfoot than LVP
  • Not flexible during install (but faster for pros)

Laminate

When it comes to dry spaces, laminate flooring is one of the best options available. It offers scratch resistance and wood-look visuals, making it ideal for flips and rental properties. Try installing it in a bedroom, office or another low-moisture area.

Why do people love laminate? Well, here are some of the advantages:

  • Affordability
  • Scratch resistance
  • Resembles hardwood
  • Straightforward installation

Even with its benefits, there are some downsides to laminate. Consider the following:

  • Not waterproof
  • Prone to warping when exposed to moisture

Engineered Hardwood

Engineered hardwood is generally the most eco-friendly flooring of these four, if you choose it wisely. Engineered hardwood consists of multiple layers of plywood arranged in a criss-cross pattern, a sturdy core and a real wood veneer top. It offers better stability and humidity resistance than solid hardwood, making it perfect for Florida homes. It’s often used in living rooms, bedrooms and other spaces where appearance matters.

What are some of the best parts about engineered hardwood? Here are some:

  • Real wood veneer provides an authentic look
  • More stable in humid climates than solid hardwood
  • Increases property value

Like its counterparts, these floors have flaws of their own. Check them out:

  • More expensive than laminate or vinyl
  • Not completely waterproof
  • Vulnerable to scratching

Tile

Tile almost never goes out of style. It’s quite versatile. In fact, it is waterproof, fire-resistant and low maintenance, making it perfect for Florida’s high humidity. Its most uses are in bathrooms, kitchens, laundry rooms and anywhere where moisture is constant.

Why has tile stood the test of time? Take a look at these benefits: 

  • Waterproof
  • Long lifespan
  • Available in various styles
  • Cools down hot rooms

With that said, tile has a couple imperfections. Think about the following:

  • Cold and hard underfoot
  • Requires professional installation
  • Not as forgiving with dropped items and pet paws

The most important part of shopping for flooring is choosing the option that’s right for you. After all, not every option will work for everyone.

Buy What Works For You

No two homes or job sites are the same. However, the right product is always out there and likely in-stock at Pro City Supply, the most trusted flooring and building material supply store in Tampa. Get started by exploring our Tampa showroom. When you shop with us, you can always count on buying like a PRO!
Ready to shop for quality flooring materials? Contact us today!

Latest Posts

Not all flooring is priced low for the same reason. What looks like a deal can turn into a nightmare three months into a job. Some look expensive, but are more than what you need. What’s the difference between cheap flooring and value flooring? It’s one of the valuable things anyone working in the industry or buying flooring can learn. Whether you're a contractor, homeowner or a flipper, trying to hit your number without cutting corners can hurt you later. Let’s get into what drives flooring prices and where the real cost shows up. What Makes Flooring Cheap in the First Place? Flooring prices are determined by several factors. The most common ones include: Wear Layer Thickness: The wear layer is the protective coating on top of SPC and LVP flooring. Budget products are 6 mil or less. Professional-grade products start 12 mil and go up. Durability makes a difference over time. Core Construction: A thin or unstable core will cause the floor to flex, shift or telegraph subfloor imperfections. Quality SPC cores are denser, heavier and more dimensionally stable. Finish Quality: Cheaper products have a lower-grade UV coating, this shows wear faster and is harder to clean without dulling. Certifications and Testing: Reputable products have FloorScore, GREENGUARD or similar certifications. Budget flooring doesn’t usually have these and clients need to know when they ask. Where It’s Sourced: Direct-from-manufacturer pricing gives you a better product for a lower price. When a product passes through two or three distributors before reaching a store shelf, you’re paying for that chain. Cheap flooring isn’t always bad. It’s just important to know what you’re buying and where it’s going. When Does Cheap Flooring Cost You More? It’s easy to choose cheap flooring because of the low upfront costs. However, it’s also easy to get burned. Here’s an overview: For Contractors When a floor fails right away, you get an angry callback. This can cost you time, materials and if the client talks, your reputation. Cheap flooring installed in the wrong place (i.e. wrong wear layer for a rental unit or wrong core for a slab with moisture issues) will fail. The client won’t blame the product, they will blame you. For Homeowners The true cost of flooring isn’t just what you pay at the counter. You have to add in the installation cost, the removal cost if it fails early and the replacement cost if it fails within five years instead of fifteen. A product that costs $0.30 less per square foot can easily set you back thousands more over time. For Flippers If you’re buying to sell, durability matters. Flooring that buckles before closing or that a home inspector flags as problematic can create delays or kill a deal. On the other end, over-specifying for a flip or using premium hardwood in a rental-grade renovation can destroy your margin just as fast. Spending the most shouldn’t be a goal. At Pro City Supply, we get that. Our Tampa building material suppliers help customers throughout Tampa, while our Orlando building material store helps Orlando customers find the right products for their projects. When you choose us, you’re buying from a trusted source you can rely on. . What Numbers Actually Matter? When you’re considering a flooring store in Tampa or flooring store in Orlando, you have to look at the product’s specs before the price tag. This means looking into the following: Wear Layer: Choose a 12 mil minimum for residential properties and 20 mil+ for heavy traffic or rentals. Total Thickness: As a rule of thumb, 5 mm is entry-level and 8 mm+ gives you better sound and stability. Core Type: SPC (Stone Polymer Composite) is the standard for dimensional stability so it doesn’t expand and contract like older LVP does in the Florida heat. Warranty: A 10-year residential warranty is reliable. A lifetime warranty on a $0.49/sq. ft. product means nothing. In-Stock Consistency: If you’re working on a 1,200 sq. ft. job and you run out of product mid-install, you have an issue. Verify lot availability before you commit. Price is the first thing you see, but it’s not the only number that matters. If you want to buy like a pro, you have to look at the product specs. How Do Pros Actually Buy? Experienced contractors don’t walk into a big-box store and grab whatever’s under the sale sign. They have a source they trust where they consistently know what’s in stock. They know the specs without having to read the back of a box so they can buy at prices that make money, not just cover materials. Buying where the pros buy makes a difference. Pricing protects contractor margins. The inventory is deep enough to handle real jobs and the people behind the counter know the trade so you’re never explaining what an SPC core is to a part-time associate. Ready to Buy Like a Pro? Are you a seasoned installer, doing your first renovation or turning investment properties for a living? Buying smart goes beyond looking at the price tag. It means knowing your specs, matching product to application and sourcing from a reliable supplier like Pro City Supply so you aren’t short on the job site. Want flooring that will last? Contact us or visit one of our showrooms today!

Not all flooring is priced low for the same reason. What looks like a deal can turn into a nightmare …

Countertop Fabrication Costs Explained

A countertop quote can add up fast so it’s important to know what you’re paying for. When you don’t, your …

Why Flooring Prices Vary So Much

Flooring prices are all over the place! One luxury vinyl plank (LVP) might set you back $2 per square foot, …

REQUEST A QUOTE